肠梗阻临床实践指南方法学质量评价

• 投稿 • 下一篇

肠梗阻临床实践指南方法学质量评价

贾俊海,杨敬致,刘爱萍,狄宝山,唐艳

甘肃省康复中心医院,甘肃省康复中心医院,甘肃卫生职业学院,甘肃省人民医院,兰州市第二人民医院

收稿日期:2018-05-15 修回日期:2018-05-15 出版日期:2018-04-25
基金资助:
兰州市人才创新创业项目 (项目编号：2015-RC-65201525；项目名称：亚高原地区急诊疾病谱相关危险因素的研究及急救优化策略)；甘肃软科学专项项目(项目编号：1604ZCRA011；项目名称：城市流浪人员医疗救助模式对策研究)

Methodological Quality Assessment of Clinical Practice Guidelines for Intestinal Obstruction

JIA Junhai,YANG Jingzhi,LIU Aiping,DI Baoshan and TANG Yan

Gansu Province Hospital Rehabilitation Center,甘肃省康复中心医院,甘肃卫生职业学院,甘肃省人民医院,兰州市第二人民医院

Received:2018-05-15 Revised:2018-05-15 Online:2018-04-25

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 目的：通过了解国内外肠梗阻指南的发布状况，评价和分析肠梗阻临床实践指南方法学质量，为临床实践提供明确的推荐意见。方法：检索PubMed、EMBASE、Web of Science、NGC、GIN、NICE、中国知网、万方和中国生物医学文献数据库等搜集肠梗阻临床实践指南。评价员独立筛选文献、提取资料后，采用AGREE Ⅱ 工具对纳入的指南进行质量评价，计算每个结构域的得分。结果：纳入10部肠梗阻临床实践指南，纳入指南的总体质量不高，无A级推荐指南，3篇指南推荐级别为B级，其余指南的推荐级别为C级。AGREE Ⅱ 6大领域得分最高为范围和目的(67.00±10.49)%，其次为清晰性(53.10±24.60)%、独立性(51.50±28.18)%、严谨性(38.70±19.96)%、应用性(22.40±6.06)%，得分最低为参与人员(20.60±12.90)%。结论：未来肠梗阻临床实践指南的制定者应该严格按照AGREE Ⅱ 条目制定肠梗阻临床实践指南，以改善肠梗阻临床实践指南的方法学质量。

Abstract: Objective： Through understanding the release status of intestind obstruction guidelines in China and abroad， we can evaluate and analyze the methodogical quality of intestind obstruction clinical practice guidelines to give reference for clinical practice.Methods：A systematic search of relevant literature databases(PubMed, EMBASE, Web of Science, NGC, GIN, NICE, CNKI, Wanfang database and CBM et al.) were conducted to identify the intestinal obstruction clinical practice guidelines. Guidelines selection and data extraction were independently performed by two authors. AGREEⅡ instrument was used to evaluate the quality of the included guidelines. Results： A total of ten guidelines for intestinal obstruction were finally included， the quality of included guidelines was not good， no guidelines was A grade recommendation， three guidelines were B grade recommendation， seven guidelines were C grade recommendation. The scores of six domains by AGREE Ⅱ instrument were (67.00±10.49)% (scope and purpose)， (53.10±24.60)% (clarity of presentation)， (51.50±28.18)% (editorial independence)，(38.70±19.96)%(rigor of development)， (22.40±6.06)% (applicability) and (20.60±12.90)%( participants).Conclusion：In the future， the researchers should develop the intestinal obstruction guidelines according to the AGREE Ⅱ instrument， so as to improve the quality of intestinal obstruction guidelines.

贾俊海,杨敬致,刘爱萍,狄宝山,唐艳. 肠梗阻临床实践指南方法学质量评价[J]. .

JIA Junhai,YANG Jingzhi,LIU Aiping,DI Baoshan and TANG Yan. Methodological Quality Assessment of Clinical Practice Guidelines for Intestinal Obstruction[J]. .

参考文献

[1]Azagury D, Liu RC, Morgan A, et al. Small bowel obstruction: A practical step-by-step evidence-based approach to evaluation, decision making, and management[J]. J Trauma Acute Care Surg, 2015, 79(4): 661-668.
[2]Taylor MR, Lalani N. Adult small bowel obstruction[J]. Acad Emerg Med, 2013,20(6): 528-544.
[3]Azagury D, Liu RC, Morgan A, Spain DA. Small bowel obstruction[J]. J Trauma Acute Care Surg,2015,79(4):661-668.
[4]Jeppesen M, Tolstrup M-B, G?genur I. Chronic pain, quality of life, and functional impairment after surgery due to small bowel obstruction[J].World J Surg,2016,40(9):2091-2097.
[5]Brouwers MC, Kho ME, Browman GP, et al. AGREE: Advancing guideline development, reporting and evaluation in healthcare[J]. Can Med Assoc J, 2010, 182(8): 839-842.
[6]Finan PJ, Campbel S, Verma R et al. The management of malignant large bowel obstruction: ACPGBI position statement[J]. Colorectal Dis,2007 Suppl 4:1-17
[7]Pekmezci S, Saribeyoglu K, Korman U. Guidelines for management of small bowel obstruction[J]. J Trauma, 2009,66(4):1262.
[8]Colombo C, Ellemunter H, Houwen R, etal. Guidelines for the diagnosis and management of distal intestinal obstruction syndrome in cystic fibrosis patients[J]. J Cyst Fibros,2011,2:S24-28.
[9]Maung AA, Johnson DC, Piper GL et al; Eastern Association for the Surgery of Trauma. Evaluation and management of small-bowel obstruction: an Eastern Association for the Surgery of Trauma practice management guideline[J].J Trauma Acute Care Surg,2012,73(5 Suppl 4):S362-9.
[10]Di Saverio S, Coccolini F, Galati M et al. Bologna guidelines for diagnosis and management of adhesive small bowel obstruction (ASBO): 2013 update of the evidence-based guidelines from the world society of emergency surgery ASBO working group[J].World J Emerg Surg,2013,8(1):42.
[11]van Hooft JE, van Halsema EE, Vanbiervliet G et al.European Society of Gastrointestinal Endoscopy. Self-expandable metal stents for obstructing colonic and extracolonic cancer: European Society of Gastrointestinal Endoscopy (ESGE) Clinical Guideline[J]. Endoscopy,2014,46(11):990-1053.
[12]Endoscopy and Cancer Committee of the French Society of Digestive Endoscopy (SFED) and the French Federation of Digestive Oncology (FFCD); Place of colorectal stents in therapeutic management of malignant large bowel obstructions[J]. Endoscopy,2014,46(6):546-552.
[13]Vogel JD, Feingold DL, Stewart DB et al; Clinical Practice Guidelines for Colon Volvulus and Acute Colonic Pseudo-Obstruction[J]. Dis Colon Rectum,2016 ,59(7):589-600.
[14]Ferrada P, Patel MB, Poylin V et al; Surgery or stenting for colonic obstruction: A practice management guideline from the Eastern Association for the Surgery of Trauma[J]. J Trauma Acute Care Surg,2016,80(4):659-664.
[15]Laval G, Marcelin-Benazech B, Guirimand F.Recommendations for bowel obstruction with peritoneal carcinomatosis[J]. J Pain Symptom Manage,2014, 48(1):75-91.
[16]Schünemann H, Bro?ek J, Guyatt GH,etal. GRADE handbook for grading quality of evidence and strength of recommendations[EB/OL].(2014-03-20)
http://www.guidelinedevelopment.org/handbook.
[17]Guyatt GH, Oxman AD, Kunz R,etal. What is ‘‘quality of evidence’’ and why is it important to clinicians?[J]. BMJ,2008,336:995-998.
[18]陈耀龙,李幼平,杜亮,等.医学研究中证据分级和推荐强度的演进[J].中国循证医学杂志,2008,8(2):127-133.
[19]Organizations that have endorsed or that are using GRADE. Available at http://www.gradeworkinggroup.org/society/index.htm. Accessed December 22, 2014
[20]Shekelle PG, Ortiz E, Rhodes S, etal. Validity of the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality clinical practice guidelines: how quickly do guidelines become outdated?[J]. JAMA, 2001,286(12):1461-1467.
[21]Strickland P, Lourie DJ, Suddleson EA,etal. Is laparoscopy safe and effective for treatment of acute small-bowelobstruction?[J]. Surg Endosc,1999,13:695–698.

快速检索引用检索图表检索高级检索